August 2026

Insights

Same Title, Different Job: Why Growing Companies Keep Hiring for the Wrong Role

Talk to us!
Insights

Last week my husband and I took our daughters to Ocean City, Maryland. We have made that drive about six times since they were babies. Same stretch of beach, same bucket of boardwalk fries, same seagulls trying to steal them, some of the same restaurants we have been going to for twenty years.

This trip was different. Every visit before this one, we spent our evenings the same way: on the boardwalk, because the girls had one priority, and it was the rides. This year, for the first time, all four of us were over 21. Nobody needed a nap schedule. Nobody was begging for one more spin on the teacups before we called it a night. We had dinner at 8:30, ended up in fun, lively bars where the crowd was every age, caught some live music, and even did karaoke as a family. Same exact destination, and it was a completely different vacation.

Nothing about Ocean City changed. We did.

I have watched the same thing happen inside growing companies for two decades, except there it costs real money.

The job description time capsule

Here is how it usually goes. A Sales Manager leaves. The company needs to backfill fast, so someone pulls the job description from the last time the role was open. Maybe they freshen up a bullet or two. The title is the same, the reporting line is the same, so it feels efficient.

But the company that wrote that job description was doing $8 million in revenue. The company posting it today is doing $40 million. Back then, the Sales Manager was a player-coach closing their own deals with two reps in the room. Today the job is building forecasting discipline, managing eight people, and working cross-functionally with marketing and finance.

Same title. Completely different job.

Then everyone is confused when the new hire, who looks exactly like the person who succeeded in the role five years ago, struggles. You did not hire the wrong person. You hired the right person for a job that no longer exists.

Why this keeps happening

Growth changes roles quietly. There is no announcement when a job evolves. It happens one new customer, one new system, one new team member at a time. The people inside the company adjust without noticing, the way parents adjust as their kids grow. You do not wake up one morning and decide your daughters are adults. It sneaks up on you, and then one day you are splitting an appetizer with them at 9 pm and realizing the old playbook does not apply.

Job descriptions do not adjust on their own. They sit in a folder, frozen at the moment they were written, describing a company that has since moved on.

Questions to ask before you post the role

Before your next opening goes live, spend thirty minutes on these:

  • What does success in this role look like today, and is that different from what the job description says?
  • What does this person own now that did not exist when the role was last filled? New systems, new markets, new team members, new compliance requirements?
  • Who will this person actually work with day to day, and have those relationships changed?
  • If the last person in the seat just left, what parts of the job did they absorb over the years that never made it onto paper?
  • Are we hiring for what the company needed for the last three years, or what it will need for the next two?

That last one matters most. If you are growing, the role will keep evolving after you fill it. The person who thrived in the old version of the job is not automatically the person who will thrive in the next one, and the reverse is true too. Some candidates who would have been wrong for the role three years ago are exactly right for it now.

We will go back to Ocean City. But I have stopped expecting it to be the trip we took when the girls were seven and four, and honestly, this version is pretty great.

The trip is never the same twice

Your company deserves the same clear-eyed look. The destination on the org chart might have the same name it always did. Before you book the trip, make sure you know who is actually going.

© 2026 Talent Retriever | All Rights Reserved | Privacy policy

Scroll to Top